Chapter 8

PROBLEMS OF AIR POLLUTION 

DR. I. H. SIDDIQUE

 

8.1 Objective:

To present an overview of problems in air pollution. 

8.2 Introduction

Air pollution is one of the most important sources of chemical hazards, especially in highly urbanized and industrialized societies. In the United States, three-quarter of the population is densely packed into 200 urban centers. These days we read and hear about the problems caused by the so called "acid rains". More than 200 million tons of toxic material are released into the air above the United States each year, about 1 ton per person. About 60% of the air pollutants come from approximately 100 million internal combustion engines, the other 40% from sources such as factories, power plants, municipal dumps and private incinerators.

Most Scientist assume "air" to be a mixture of the gases listed in Table I.

Table I. Components of Normal Dry Air

Nitrogen 780,900 ppm

Oxygen 209,400 ppm

Argon 9,300 ppm

Carbon Dioxide 315 ppm

Neon 18 ppm

Helium 5.2 ppm

Methane 1.0 to 1.2 ppm

Krypton 1.0 ppm

Nitrous oxide 0.5 ppm

Hydrogen 0.5 ppm

Xenon 0.08 ppm

Nitrogen dioxide 0.02 ppm

Ozone 0.01 to 0.04 ppm

Air pollutants may be defined as those substances which exist in such concentrations as to cause an unwanted effect. These pollutants can be natural (such as smoke from forest fires) and can be in the form of gases or particulates. (liquid or solid particles larger than 1 micron).

8.3 Gaseous Pollutants

In the context of air pollution control, gaseous pollutants include substances that are gases are normal temperature and pressure as well as vapors of substances that are liquid or solid at normal temperature and pressure. Among the gaseous pollutants of greatest importance in terms of present knowledge are carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, hydrogen sulfide, nitrogen oxides, ozone and other oxidants and sulfur oxides. carbon dioxide should be added to this list because of its potential effect on climate. 

8.4 Particulate Pollutants:

Particulate pollutants are classified as follows:

8.4.1 Dust

Solid particles which are:

8.4.2 Fume

A solid particle, frequently a metallic oxide, formed by the condensation of vapors by sublimation, distillation, calcination or chemical reaction processes. Examples of fumes are zinc and lead oxide resulting from the condensation and oxidation of metal volatilized in a high-temperature process. The particles in fumes are quite small, with diameters from 0.03 microns.

8.4.3. Mist

A liquid particle formed by the condensation of a vapor and perhaps by chemical reaction. An illustration of this process is the formation of sulfuric acid mist:

8.4.5. Sulfur Gases

- SO (gas) 22 C SO (liquid)

- SO (liquid) + H 0 H S0

- Sulfur trioxide gas becomes a liquid since its dew point is 22 C and SO particles are hydroscopic. Mists typically range from 0.5 to 3.0 microns in diameter.

8.4.6 Smoke

Solid particles formed as a result of incomplete combustion of carbonaceous materials. While hydrocarbons, organic acids, sulfur oxides, and nitrogen oxides are also produced in combustion processes, only the solid particles resulting from the incomplete combustion of carbonaceous materials are smoke. Smoke particles have diameters ranging from 0.05 to approximately 1 micron.

8.4.7 Spray

A liquid particle formed by the atomization of a parent liquid.

8.5 Effects of Air pollutants

The key to the realm of air pollution control is the effect on the health and welfare of people, property and environment. The air pollution loss syndrome is depicted in Table 2.

 

Table 2. Air Pollution Loss Syndrome

Visibility Reduction Miscellaneous Human Health

Aesthetics Waste contamination Odors

Accident Global aspects Acute episodes

Depressed Combustion Losses Chronic Illnesses

Land values Radioactivity Time off work

Mental depression Bronchitis

Loss of sunlight Emphysema

Asthma

General well-being 

Vegetation Loss from Animal Health

Direct loss Air Fluorosis

Loss in yield Pollution Lead, arsenic, etc.

Reduced land Radioactivity

values Acute or chronic

(Subacute) 

Government Costs Manufacturing Costs Inert Material

Research Equipment Paper, Books

Development Maintenance Leather

Enforcement Disposal Fabrics

Legal action Development Paint

Information Lawsuits Building, Stone

Education Production losses Metals

Training Clean room costs Rubber

Conferences Electrical contacts

Agency cost Replacement

Cleaning

Deterioration

8.6 Air Pollution Effects on Human Health

Much of our knowledge of the effects of air pollution on people comes from the study of acute air pollution episodes. The three most famous episodes occurred in the Meuse Valley of Belgium, in Donora, Pennsylvania, and in London, England. Some of the essential features of these episodes are in Table 3. Features common to these episodes are of particular interest. In all three the illness appeared to be chemical irritation of the respiratory tract. The weather circumstances were also similar in that a high pressure system with an inversion layer was present.

In all three episodes, the pollutants affected a specific segment of the public those individuals already suffering from diseases of the cardiorespiratory system. Another observation of great importance is that upon investigation it was not possible to blame the adverse effects upon any one pollutant. Today, after many years of study it is thought that the health problems during the Donora, Meuse and London episodes were attributed to the combined action of a particulate matter (solid or liquid particle) and sulfur dioxide, a gas.

 

Table 3. Comparison of the three Major Air Pollution Episodes

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Muese Valley,1930 Donora, 1948 London, 1952

------------------------------------------------------------------

Weather High pressure High pressure High pressure

inversion and inversion and inversion and fog fog fog

Topography River valley River valley River plain

Most probable Industry Industry Household source of pollutants (including (including coal-burning steel and zinc steel and zinc plants) plants)

Natural of the Chemical irri- Chemical irrita- Chemical irri- illnesses tation of ex- tion of exposed ation of surfaces posed membranous membranous surfaces surfaces 

Death among these Yes Yes Yes with pre-existing cardiorespiratory disease

Time of death Began after sec- Began after sec- Began after ond day of epi- ond day of epi- first day of sode sode episode

Ratio of illnesses Not available 75:1 to 300:1 Unexpected increased numbers of illnesses and deaths

Autopsy findings Inflammatory Inflammatory Lesion lesions in lungs lesions did not included included include parenchyma parenchyma parenchyma

Suspected proximate Sulfur oxides Sulfur oxides Sulfur oxides cause of irritation with particulates with particulates with particulates

------------------------------------------------------------------

Effects on human health may be acute due to short high level exposures-increased mortality among the elderly and the persons ill with chronic diseases (like bronchitis asthma and heart attacks). Air pollutants in asthma patients have been shown to increase levels of globulins in their blood.

Long-term effects of low-level exposures to polluted air may lead to chronic disease such as cancerous growths and genetic mutations; general body defense mechanisms are impaired, and physiologic function interfered with. Lung cancer has been correlated with air pollution as well as with certain other factors such as smoking habits.

8.7 Air Pollution Effects on Animals

The mechanism by which an animal can become affected by air pollution is entirely different from that of humans. With animals, we are concerned with a two-step process: the accumulation of airborne contaminants in vegetation and forage which serves as cattle food and the subsequent effect of the ingested contaminated herbage on the animal. Air pollutants that present a hazard to livestock are those which are taken up by vegetation and react in the plant to form toxic substances.

Table 4 contains a list of the major pollutants with respect to animals. Arsenic and lead have been pollutants which affected animals in the past and are no longer of importance because emissions have been controlled. As the effects of some pollutants are reduced because of air pollution control, new pollutants take the place of the old.

The report of organic phosphates (nerve gas) killing 6200 sheep is a rarity (Chemical and Engineering News, 1968). Although this type of air pollution episode may never occur again, it clearly points out the result of an accidental emission of a dangerous chemical on the living objects in the area. Findings of high mercury levels in tuna and swordfish have shocked the public and complacent governmental agencies.

Some 75% of phosphate are in the United States is in Polk and Hillsborough Counties in Florida. Fluoride emissions from industries producing phosphate fertilizers or phosphate derivatives are detrimental to the growth of cattle, citrus, and commercial row crops. The affected area in Florida covers some 600 sq miles; the cattle population decrease by 30,00 head between 1953 and 1960 (Special Subcommittee Hearings on Air and Water Pollution, 1964). Although much remains to be done to reduce the fluoride emissions in Florida, research has diagnosed fluorosis in cattle and has published safe ingestion levels (Greenwood et al., 1964). No adverse effects on cattle were found at 15-30 ppm fluorine and chronic fluorosis was noted at 60-109 ppm; acute fluorosis occurred when the fluoride content of forage exceeded 250 ppm fluorine in the moisture-free diet.

 

Table 4. Air Pollutant Effects to Animal Health

------------------------------------------------------------------

Pollution Effects, injury levels

------------------------------------------------------------------

Arsenic Severe colic (salivation, thirst vomiting), odor of garlic on breath, diarrhea and bloody feces. Cattle sicken on alfalfa containing 40-50 ppm As2O3, 10 mg As/gm body wt-day.

Lead Excitable jerking of muscles, frothing at mouth, grinding of teeth, paralysis of larynx muscles to eventual stupor and death Cattle sicken on herbage containing 25-50 ppm Pb.

Organic Phosphates (Nerves gas) Increased uncoordinated muscle activity, followed by

paralysis and death. 6200 sheep reported dead from nerve gas (anticholinesterase agents) of 820 gal released from a high-speed aircraft "approximately" 27 miles from nearest sheep herd.

Fluorides Lack of appetite, loss in body weight, lameness,

periodic diarrhea, marked and worn teeth. Cattle vary in sensitivity. Dairy cattle affected at fluoride levels greater than 30-50 ppm in herbage or approximately 2 gm F/kg body wt-day.

 

VIII. Air Pollution Effects on Vegetation

Vegetation damage is not a major problem in urban areas; vegetation damage normally results from emissions from and industrial plant located away from crowded areas. Major pollutants affecting vegetation are presented in Table No. 5.

 

 

Table 5. Major Pollutants affecting Vegetation

Pollutant Leaf markings, injury levels

------------------------------------------------------------------

Sulfur Usually interveinal necrotic blotches bleached dioxide white to straw color. Spongy parenchymal cells initially affected. Oldest leaves less resistant. Insect, injury, winter and drought conditions may show similar markings. Alfalfa, barley, cotton, etc. sensitive at 0.25-0.3 ppm; plant cells have capacity to detoxify SO2 or SO3 at a definite rate. Sulfur levels in leaf varies from 0.1-0.6% (dry).

Oxidant Silvered or bronzed appearance usually on underside of smog gases leaf, Initial collapse in spongy parenchyma. Youngest leaves react first, insect and "sun scald" may show similar markings.

Ozone Upper surface stipple or flecking with small irregular collapsed areas bleached white to straw color. Initial effect in palisade layer, Tomato, tobacco, bean sensitive at 0.2 ppm.

Nitrogen Brown margins and brown to black spots on leaves.

oxides Mature and middle-aged leaves most sensitive. Fluorides Pinto beans symptoms at 3 ppm. Necrotic "burned" tip or on edges of leaf. Narrow brown-red band separates necrotic from green tissue. Fungal diseases, wind and high temperatures, drought and cold temperatures may show similar markings.

Ethylene Epinasty and/or abcission without markings. Young leaves recover rapidly; older leaves do not recover

fully. Water stress may produce similar effects. Orchids sensitive at 0.005 ppm; tomatoes sensitive at 0.1 ppm Acetylene, olefinic hydrocarbons and carbomonoxide produce similar effects at higher concentrations.

------------------------------------------------------------------

 

8.9 Air Pollution Effects on Inert Materials

Air pollution effects on inert materials depend on the type and concentration of the pollutant and the type and time exposed of the materials involved. Some of these effects are:

Air pollution effects on inert materials depend on the type and concentration of the pollutant and the type and time exposed of the materials involved. Some of these effects are:

8.10 Standards Development

In order to achieve the standards set by 1970 Federal Clean Air Act in an orderly manner, the following tasks were undertaken:

In order to develop an adequate control strategy, considerable information is necessary regarding air quality and air pollutant emissions.

Ideally, control strategy development evolves as a series of interrelated efforts:

(1) Emission Inventory

(2) Ambient Air Monitoring to Establish Existing Levels and Trends

(3) Strategy Development

Regulations assume many forms - all aimed at limiting the amount of pollutants being emitted into the atmosphere.

Control techniques also assume many forms such as fuel switching, prohibition of certain practices such as open burning, process modifications, reduction of vehicle miles or improved traffic flow and installation of control devices. The type of air pollution control device depends on the pollutant to be captured, the process involved, and the regulations to be met.

Mechanically collectors are usually only used as per-cleaners, since their efficiency on small particles is low. Wet collectors come in many forms and are used to collect gases and particulates. Baghouses are normally thought of as having the highest efficiency for particulates. Electrostatic precipitators are also considered as a high efficiency control device. Afterburners are often used for gas (CO) and vapor (hydrocarbons) carbons control. Many control systems employ a combination of control and gas conditioning devices. Meteorology also plays a significant role in air pollution control activities. Inversions and stagnant air masses cause abnormal accumulation of pollutants. If you consider just a long vertical column of the atmosphere, you can reduce the atmospheric pressure is the weight exerted on a parcel of air by the column above it. Therefore, pressure decreases as altitude increases. This one reason smoke rises - it is actually being pushed from a high pressure area to a lower pressure. Another reason smoke rises is temperature. Hot air is lighter than cold air. Therefore, pollutants emitted at ground level where temperature is normally higher than it is at elevated altitudes tend to rise. However, an inversion reverses this normally temperature profile of the atmosphere and actually "traps" the pollutants.

Inversion

Aloft

Surface

Inversion

Increasing T

(Normal -54° F/1,000 ft.)

Horizontal air movement also effects pollution levels by increasing or decreasing the diffusion of pollutants.

In order to develop additional strategies, we must better understand the causes of the violations and the relative contributions of various sources.

 

XI. References

Jacobs, M. B., (ed.), Analytical Chemistry of Industrial Poisons, Hazards & Solvents, Interscience Publishers, (latest edition).

Metcalf & Eddy, Inc., Wastewater Engineering, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1972.

Patty, F. A., (ed.), Industrial Hygiene & Toxicology, (2 Volume Edition), Interscience Publishers, Inc., 1958.

Stern, A. C., (ed.), Air pollution, (3 Volume Edition), Academic Press, 1968.

U. S. DHHS, Public Health Service Drinking Water Standards, Washington, D.C. (latest edition).

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Decision Makers Guide in Solid Waste Management (SW-127), Washington, D.C., 1974.

 

XII. References on Reserve

 
AL-Layla , M. A., Ahmad, S., Middlebrooks, E. J., Water Supply Engineering Design, Ann Arbor Publishers Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1977.

Cheremisinoff, P.N. and Morresi, A.C., Environmental Assessment of Impact Statement Handbook by Ann Arbor Science Publishers Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1977.

Colley, J. R. T. Chapter 9, Respiratory system, in: Oxford Textbook of Public Health, Volume 4, Specific Applications, edited by Holland, W. H., Detels, R., and Knox, G. Oxford University Press, 1985.

Ehlers, V. M. and Steel, E. W. Chapter 2, Air Pollution and Its Control, in: Municipal and Rural Sanitation, 6th edition. McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1965.

Hoover, T. R. Chapter 20, Air, soil, and water, in: Principles of Health Maintenance, edited by Schnurrenberger, P. R. and Sharman, R. S. Praeger Publishers, New York, 1983.

Kilburn, K. H. Chapter 23, Pulmonary responses to gases, in: Maxcy-Rosenau-Last Public Health and Preventive Medicine, 13th edition, edited by Last, J. M. and Wallace, R. B. Appleton and Lange, Norwalk, CT, 1992.

Purdom, P. W.., Environmental Health, Academic Press, New York, 1971.

Steel, E. W., Water Supply and Sewage, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1960.

Vesilind, P. A., Environment Pollution and Control, Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1975.

Waller, R. E. Chapter 18, Field Investigations of Air, in: Oxford Textbook of Public Health, edited by Holland, W. H., Detels, R., and Knox, G. Oxford University Press, 1985.

 

 

XIII. Questions

1. What are the effects of air pollution on human health?

2. What are the effects of air pollution on animal health?

3. What are the effects of air pollution on vegetation?

4. What are the effects of air pollution on inert materials?

5. What is acid rain?

6. Name at least 8 components of air.

7. Identify at least 5 particulate pollutants of air.

8. Is air pollution a problem in rural areas as it is in metropolitan areas relative to animal health? Explain.